the family law act gave the family court and federal circuit court a wide discretion
why did the law give the court a wide discretion?
The wide discretionary power of courts in property settlement cases allows them to be able to make a just and equitable order considering the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case.
The Family Law Act gave the Family Court and Federal Circuit Court a wide discretion in deciding property settlement disputes. Courts are guided with principles of equality and a four step approach but it is up to the judge or magistrate to apply these in the case.
It is because every case is different from the other. In every case the situation of the parties, their contributions, their assets and liabilities, and their capacities to provide financially are different from other couples who are also applying for property division. Given this diversity it would be very impractical if the power of courts to decide is limited. The discretion of the court to decide recognizes that fairness can only be achieved if the case is decided on its own merit.
A married person must file an application with the court within a year from the time the divorce became final while a de facto partner must do so within two years from the breakdown of the relationship.
A four step approach is followed by the court in coming up with a fair and reasonable property order.
The first step is identifying the net assets of the parties. All the properties will be taken into account including business interests, financial sources and prospective sources of income as long as the party exercises control or interest over it like stocks and bonds.
Next is assessment of the contributions of the parties. Contributions may be financial or non-financial. It may be that the party is contributing salary, his labour or his being a homemaker. Inheritances and gifts received will likewise be accounted.
The third step is to identify the future needs of both parties. For this step there are many factors to consider including the age and health of the parties, their ability or the probability to still be employed and earn an income, whether either of them has a dependent in their care or if either of them is in another relationship. These factors will be important in the decision making of the judge.
Finally, the court will make orders that have practical effect for both parties. Justness and equality are the main considerations for this step.
Not really. Financial contributions and ownership of assets is not the sole consideration for an award of property settlement. This is the benefit of courts having a wide discretionary power because they can make an order based on their appreciation of the totality of the circumstances of the parties.
Disclaimer : This article provides basic information only and is not a substitute for a professional or legal advice. It is prudent to obtain legal advice from a family lawyer.